Laurelville Pizza: A Hidden Gem in Laurelville, OH

By far the best pizza's we've ever had. My daughter loved the cheese pizza and we got a Veggie lovers. The veggies tasted so fresh! Sauce and crust were both delicious ans perfect as well. All of us were very impressed. They have a large selection, also drinks, candy, sweets. The staff was so kind and felt very much like home! Highly recommend. I'm excited to go back and try out some subs and their other selections! Thank you all for your amazing service. My family and i appreciated it .

First time ordering, and we found a gem! The restaurant was not what I thought, it was very cute and tidy. Hard ice cream available inside, lots different yummy flavors. It has a couple picnic tables out front as well. (This is written in past tensed because the food was so good it was eaten with delicious vigor)! Pizzas were so delicious and generous toppings. The crust of the pizza different then any others pizza we've ever had. Crispy and amazing ... and very delicious! The Bavarian pretzel sticks and mild cheddar cheese dip was really good. Mozzarella cheese sticks were highly praised. Chef salad was very generous in all the topping and fresh! The lady that answered the phone was very helpful, polite and kind. She didn't act like she minded all my questions and patient and answered the questions throughly. I spoke briefly with the cook and he was also very kind and considerate as well. Five stars all around for this awesome gem of a small hometown pizza restaurant!

We stayed in Laurelville for a Hocking Hills trip, and our AirBnB recommended Laurelville pizza. We placed an order and were amazed at how delicious this pizza was! Fast forward a year, and we were back for another trip. We stayed in the same cabin and as soon as we checked in, we could not wait to order Laurelville pizza again! It is absolutely delicious; a pizza we had been thinking about for a year! The pizza is so good, but the staff is above and beyond. They are so kind and accommodating and friendly. We made sure to make a stop in every day of our trip for a scoop or two of ice cream as well! A few days post trip, and we are still thinking about Laurelville Pizza's pizza and ice cream. HIGHLY recommend! We live 5 hours away, but I know we WILL be back.

This is the cutest pizza place I have ever been to. We were traveling through Laurelville coming back from vacation and even though they were closed they were nice enough to still let us order a pizza. The nicest people with unique decor that kept us entertained while we waited. They were friendly and the pizza and bread sticks were absolutely amazing. Will definitely make sure we come back here on our next time through.

I tried them out a few weeks ago. I had the best Veggie pizza that I have ever had. Very friendly service, and a nice inside dining area.

Absolutely amazing food! Wonderful service. And the atmosphere is totally fun! Took lots of pictures while waiting on our food!

This restaurant is an incredible find! We ordered while traveling in the area. The service staff was friendly and helpful, the atmosphere of the restaurant is fun and super clean, and the food was phenomenal. We had pizza the first night (the best I’ve had in a long time!) and went back for a sub the next day (the Italian was delicious). The food is all super fresh, with quality ingredients, and it shows. We will definitely be returning!

The lady at the register was sweet, considerate to all customers, and thoughtful. I'd go back just to chat with her again. The ice cream was very good too, though the paper sure is hard to remove from the waffle cone for a guy with no fingernails.